| Girls Middlesex League All Stars for 2004 | ||
| Bel | Liander, Margit | 2005 |
| Bel | Reder, Hillary | 2007 |
| Burl | Gamez, Nicole | 2008 |
| Lex | Heymann, Marilyn | 2005 |
| Lex | Kernan, Elizabeth | 2008 |
| Lex | McNabb, Jill | 2007 |
| Mel | Johnson, Betsy | 2005 |
| Sto | Bradley, Janelle | 2005 |
| Sto | Wantman, Amber | 2006 |
| Wak | Inman, Marybeth | 2005 |
| Wat | Burk, Sandy | 2008 |
| Win | Eidmann, Katherina | 2006 |
| Win | O'Connell, Barbara | 2005 |
| Win | Keating, Jennifer | 2005 |
| Lex | Sullivan, Kate | 2006 |
| Boys Middlesex League All Stars for 2004 | |||
| Team | Number | Name | YOG |
| Bel | 54 | Simran Fitzgerald | 2006 |
| Bur | 7 | Faller, Jesse | 2006 |
| Bur | 3 | McMillan, Bennett | 2005 |
| Bur | 1 | Tirrell, Matt | 2006 |
| Lex | 69 | Morris, Paul | 2005 |
| Lex | 2 | Noonan, JP | 2005 |
| Mel | 12 | Savery, Jon CC | 2005 |
| Rea | 88 | Horn, Sam | 2006 |
| Rea | 73 | O'Leary, Ian | 2005 |
| Sto | 54 | Fixman, Randy | 2005 |
| Wat | 14 | Jablon, Matt | 2007 |
| Win | 4 | Laliberte, Justin CC | 2005 |
| Win | 7 | Richard, Paul CC | 2005 |
| Lex | 26 | Brown, David | 2007 |
| Lex | 52 | Kim, Tim | 2007 |